Starmer backs ban on trans women from female-only hospital wards
May 1, 2024Sir Keir Starmer, leader of the Labour party, has stated that his perspectives on gender issues “start with biology,” supporting the exclusion of trans women from female-only hospital wards and prisons.
This announcement aligns with the Government’s initiation of a consultation considering alterations to the NHS Constitution, potentially leading to trans patients receiving treatment in individual rooms if other patients insist on single-sex wards.
Image Credit: Canva
Officials promote the revisions as a means to “put patients first.” However, the British Medical Association has expressed concerns that these modifications may restrict the access of transgender and non-binary patients to essential NHS services.
In a conversation on ITV’s Good Morning Britain, Sir Keir remarked, “There's a distinction between sex and gender. The Labour Party has a long history of advocating for women’s rights.”
According to ‘Yahoo! News’, when queried about Labour's approach to transgender women who oppose being placed in male hospital wards, he responded, “We have to accommodate that situation as it arises but treat everybody with respect and dignity… I do not accept this is an issue that cannot be resolved with respect and dignity.”
He continued, “Where we need to make accommodations, we can make accommodations… As a country, we’re a pretty reasonable tolerant bunch and most people know that there are a small number of individuals who do not identify with the gender that they were born into.”
“A lot of them experience considerable distress and trauma. From my perspective, I’m perfectly willing to treat them, as I would anyone else, with respect.”
The changes also aim to incorporate Martha’s Rule into the NHS Constitution to enhance patient safety.
With the proposed adjustments, transgender individuals may be assigned to private rooms if another patient demands a single-sex ward.
This arrangement would be allowable under the Equality Act 2010 when appropriate, such as honouring a patient's preference for a single-sex ward, as stated by the Department of Health and Social Care.
In October, former health secretary Steve Barclay considered amending the constitution to respond to concerns regarding trans women accessing wards designated for biologically female patients.
Health and Social Care Secretary Victoria Atkins emphasised the government’s commitment to ensuring that “biological sex is respected” within the NHS, arguing that the term “woman” should not be “eradicated from our language to be inclusive and welcoming.”
Speaking to Sky News, she stated, “We want to ensure that biological sex is respected and that if someone wants, for example, an intimate examination by a person of the same biological sex, then they can request that, and it will be handled properly, respecting the individual’s right to privacy, dignity, and safety.”
“This is necessary because navigating these discussions has sometimes been challenging for staff. We're aiming to clarify these policies for both patients and staff, allowing them to make these requests.”
The document revision will also make provisions to accommodate different biological needs and ensure that diseases affecting men and women differently are clearly communicated to patients.
Shadow health secretary Wes Streeting noted, “Rights on paper are worthless unless they are realized in practice.”
“The NHS Constitution already guarantees that no patient should have to share an overnight ward with patients of the opposite sex, yet this standard is frequently not met,” he further commented.
“Labour supports single-sex wards and is committed to providing the necessary staff, investments, and reforms to ensure the safe care of every patient.”
Dr. Emma Runswick, deputy chairwoman of the British Medical Association Council, cautioned that some proposed changes might be more detrimental than beneficial, potentially leading to increased discrimination, harassment, and marginalisation of an already vulnerable group.
“If these proposed changes are implemented, transgender and non-binary patients will potentially find their access to crucial NHS services restricted,” she concluded.
The NHS Constitution, which delineates the rights of patients and staff, is updated every decade.
Other proposed modifications undergoing an eight-week consultation process include a commitment to providing families with the option of a second opinion when a patient’s condition deteriorates.
Read related myGwork articles here:
“Humiliating and hurtful”: Trans+ people react to Keir Starmer backing sports ban
Keir Starmer to outlaw all forms of conversion therapy if Labour wins election
Turning Trans Issues Into A “Toxic Divide” Doesn’t Help, Says Keir Starmer
Keir Starmer Wants To “Modernize” Trans Laws But Thinks 16 Is Too Young To Change Gender
Keep up to date with the latest myGnews