Wyoming Librarian awarded $700,000 settlement after wrongful termination over LGBTQ+ books

Terri Lesley, a former library director in Wyoming, has been awarded a $700,000 settlement after being terminated for refusing to remove books with LGBTQ+ themes from the children's and young adult sections of the Campbell County Public Library.

Lesley filed a federal lawsuit alleging defamation and violation of her First Amendment rights after being fired in 2021. The lawsuit claimed that county officials retaliated against her for defending the presence of LGBTQ+ books in the library, which had been challenged by community members.

As reported by New York Times, the dispute began after the library highlighted LGBTQ+ books during Pride Month in June 2021. Soon after, challenges were made against approximately 25 books, including titles like "This Book is Gay" by Juno Dawson and "How Do You Make a Baby" by Anna Fiske. Critics argued that these books should be moved to the adult section to "protect" children, a claim Lesley firmly opposed.

Lesley maintained that segregating these books would constitute censorship and limit access for young people seeking information on these topics. While she received support from the community and was recognized for her leadership, she was ultimately fired after facing mounting pressure from county officials.

Following the settlement, Lesley expressed relief and reaffirmed her commitment to defending the First Amendment. Her lawyer, Iris Halpern, emphasized the importance of upholding constitutional rights and ensuring equal access to public institutions for all members of the community, regardless of their differences.

While the county did not comment directly on the settlement, a lawyer representing its insurance company stated that it was settled "early" to avoid an expensive federal trial.

This case highlights the ongoing battle over book bans and challenges in schools and libraries across the United States, with LGBTQ+ books frequently targeted by conservative groups. It also underscores the importance of librarians and educators standing up for intellectual freedom and ensuring access to diverse perspectives for all members of the community.

A separate lawsuit filed by Lesley against three family members for defamation and intentional infliction of emotional distress is ongoing.